[sDOM.I] Proposed rankings!

[HULKSMASH]

After taking into consideration your rankings and feedback in the other thread, here are our initial proposed rankings.

What do you think? See any glaring errors? Your constructive feedback is appreciated!



bleh-
p^
ramdrop
ravonix
Monk
Viperzz^
Cromaniac
Rum
MP/5
bug
Sens
blackout\\
Junkyardboy
rain
Morpheus
HUMPTY
Steel
Dewsick
Sauron
Sunny
snky
csnafk
THEINCREDIBLEPACO
KNOCKOUTDAD
lockpick
Xenoscythe
kud
risus`
miracle
ulo
Banko
RickJames
ApokaL1pS
ScReaM
Supreme
rev
gzt
flowX
booth
exixt
danon3^
whitechocakagod
tigerclaw
bbz
insanity
ttocston
mng
AnNiHiL4ToR
rootsoft
Spriggan
massie
Sponge
dev
cafe
Lineage
wndg
ttocston
Einfari
akito
crux
kevinsan1ty
Hermione
XhackZ
pwnage
CrashedMC
xios
JINNZILLA
HULKSMASH
E|ite
Bryandigm-
JD
rasta-man
Blue_Armature
b1o
NakedMan
Ales
Pun`
Tempus
Imperious
Neddy
Sovvie
ttn
linoleumbonaparte
Shotman
krm`
snakeware
iiSpyz
D4RR3N
nightwing
clankiller
Sylia
otb (?)
Se7eN
Zac
SK8 (?) *
NiNjA][GAiDEN
z4TaN
Bittin
Murder
KillEmAll
HakunaMatata
Chamberly

[ramdrop]

I believe:

otb is massie under another registration name?

I think (as massie has next to no experience), he is ranked a little too high.

whitechoc has a fair bit of sdom experience and is ranked a little lower, above flowX for sure.

Sponge too, can hold 1on1 spots by himself, up with flowX.

Nakedman is a steal at that price imo, same with Hermione despite his nomic.

The top 10, I feel needs to be reworked, jyb and blackout are rather low (blackout especially despite this is powerup timings) rummy should be above me, as should Monk - but thats just my 2 cents.

[Viperzz^]

Cromaniac's breath in my neck feels good. Rum higher than me.

[rain]

Morph above me, Xeno could go a bit higher as well, even above me... he was pretty much a dominate all-star last season for his team and was a first round pick..

[RickJames]

PACO is way too low, there is not a point in sdom that he would ever lose to sauron, csn, etc

Sens and morph are too high- both are good, but they've never performed at that level in sdom.

Too many problems imo. I'll make a new list here, based on Humpty's (I think most of agreed that his list was the closest in the other thread), with some influence from me and mp^5 and new guys added in:

bleh-
Monk
ramdrop
p^
Rum
ravonix
MP/5
Viperzz^
bug
Cromaniac
Junkyardboy
blackout\\
SunnY
rain
paleface
HUMPTY
THEINCREDIBLEPACO
Sens
Morpheus
KNOCKOUTDAD
snky
lockpick
Steel
Dewsick
Xenoscythe
n0b
csnafk
miracle
whitechocakagod
Sauron
risus`
flowX
kud
Banko
gzt
Sponge
booth
ApokaL1pS
ulo
RickJames
ScReaM
exixt
danon3^
bbz
insanity
rootsoft
AnNiHiL4ToR
Spriggan
crux *
ttocston
mng
cafe
massie
Supreme
rev
dev
wndg
tigerclaw
Lineage
Hermione
XhackZ
pwnage
CrashedMC
xios (?)
JINNZILLA
HULKSMASH
E|ite (?)
Bryandigm-
JD
akito
rasta-man
Blue_Armature ?
b1o
NakedMan
Ales
Pun`
Imperious
Se7eN
Tempus
Neddy
kevinsan1ty
Sovvie
linoleumbonaparte
Shotman
krm`
snakeware
iiSpyz
D4RR3N
nightwing
clankiller
Einfari
ttn
Sylia
otb (?)
Zac
SK8 (?) *
HakunaMatata (?)
NiNjA][GAiDEN
z4TaN
Murder
KillEmAll
Bittin (?) *
Chamberly

[NakedMan]

As i've said already im overrated at that list as players who are lower than me on it have beat me in 1v1 spots already.
I think whitechoc and sponge are really underrated.

[ravonix]

I should probably be 4-5 steps lower in that list, dont think i'm that good really since i loose to those people on many positions.

[Supreme]

Sponge and Spriggan above me. Spriggan is very good, beat me on corner cp on nitro a while back. Guy was shooting 50 acc in pugs at one point. I'd also say JD should be a bit higher.

[d3R]

[Monk]

I'd agree that ravonix and Sens could be a little lower. ramdrop maybe down a few places, but pretty close amongst the top 10

[Sens]

If I start pug/practicing again I doubt I'd get close to some of those guys around my ranking. Last season I reckon I finished somewhere between xeno & sauron, played a lot of ictf since then yes but I don't know how much that would help D:

[JINNZILLA]

why is neddy ranked so high and linoleum so low?

[Blue_Armature]

Wow I should not be ranked so high, nomic + no sDOM experience + inconsistent aim. Never mind, saw the other thread now.

[Sauron]

I'm ranked way too high, that's for damn sure.

[rev]

The rankings by RJ are much more accurate than the original. Aside from maybe top ten, so many errors with original I'm not sure where to start.

[PACO]

[NakedMan]

[ttocston]

I don't think I should be that high up.

[Cromaniac]

Ok, so lets try to break down the list into smaller segments instead of always coming up with entire new list? And i ll try emphasize the biggest differences so you can focus on discussing more of those. I think we can agree that +- 1/2 spots isn't really important.

So the 2 lists have exactly the same top 10 just in different order. Does it really make a big difference? Everyone there has their own spots, pluses and minuses. Otherwise, i don't think discussing order of them more precisely is really possible. It would just be subjective opinions, as will be mine. Biggest difference there is rums placement.
d.
Next 10: Pretty similar in both lists.
Biggest differences: Sauron (19th / 28th) Csn is put pretty close to him on both. Putting him spot under csn (23rd) could be a good compromise. Mistakes imo: Second list puts him below miracle and whitechock. first one above Paco, Knockoutdad.

THEINCREDIBLEPACO (23rd / 16th) Here, i agree more with second one. Paco shouldn't be below csn, snky, Dewsick or Sauron. Second one: he shouldn't be above Steel?

Steel (15 /21) M imo: On second, below lockpick, Paco and snky. That brings him on difference of 3 which is more acceptable.

Sens (11 / 17) Idk so i put him in between.

Dewsick (8 / 13) Dewsick has a lot of potential but is very inexperienced. Right now i wouldn't place him above snky, sunny, Paco or Knockout as in first.

So far first 25. Xeno might come before Sauron.
bleh-
p^
ramdrop
Monk
Viperzz^
ravonix
MP/5
Cromaniac
Rum?
bug
blackout\\
Junkyardboy
rain
Sens
Morpheus
HUMPTY
Steel
Sunny
THEINCREDIBLEPACO
KNOCKOUTDAD
snky
Dewsick
lockpick
csnafk
Sauron

If this is acceptable i can try to continue.

[HULKSMASH]

Good post Cro I like

[rain]

Again, players like Sens, Morph, Sunny, Paco all have more experience, more pugs, more knowledge and overall better sdom players than myself (not that I'm trying to get myself lower but captains take this into consideration when picking, this isn't ictf )

[Morpheus]

I haven't been around for a bit but RJ rankings seem a lot closer to the reality i remember

[PACO]

I think that the only logical thing to do at this point is to bump everyone down 5 slots.

edit: on the real, good post so far from Cro however I think you are underrating snky and Dew.

[Sauron]

I should be down around LP/Apok by the looks of it.

[HUMPTY]

agree@ snky higher.. hes better than me..i think it was season 1 he raped the shit outa ph34r on campgrounds..
paco should also be up 4 or 5 slots

[KNOCKOUTDAD]

[unrealshots]

*yawn

[Zac]

*face palms* excuse me, i see terrible sdom players above me...
still concerned about why im put below people that have never played a single sdom game before, don't speak english, or dont even have a mic...

i have 29 eff , 35 sdom matches 12 hours total, 20 acc, perfect english communication and know all the maps by now, all boosts included.
why am i like 50 fucking dollars?

* i did reference this twice in the previous rankings

[tigerclaw]

from around 7pm to 2am my connection is useless, i get at best 25 acc - this will be the same for at least one game

map knowledge 2/10
powerup control 9/10
aim 7/10
movement 8/10
point control 7/10

nomic

ranking me around windigo's level seems fine

[KillEmAll]

Zac, the lower your ranked the better, unless you have a fragile ego.
Enjoy it and prove your a ringer at that price.