You guys should not confuse an attacker with awsome fragpower who can also defend with real defenders. That makes a HUGE difference when you are picking players for each position.
I just picked the ones I already played against since it would be unfair to judge players i didn't play yet (i can update my list as soon as i pug more).
Since I'm a defender who occasionally attacks (maybe 1 map for every 50 i play ??) I mainly picked attackers:
TOP D: Serenity -> knows how to defend in every single map that says it all; perfect positioning + frag power
OTHERS: Ravonix -> i know him since ClanBase just an amazing defender
UnrealShots -> the times I played a pug against him he was defending and so do i so i don't know much about him but from the stats he looks incredible strong
JYB -> amazing frag power with some lack of positioning when defending otherwise he could be the best D in the league along with Serenity
Snap -> fantastic defender to play with; greats communications + positioning
Finalz -> same as Ravonix and Snap fantastic defender
Fisk -> top D which i think is always underrated
Ramdrop -> every consistent player i like his D skills
Paleface -> a monster since ClanBase days top top defender in my opinion
Nick -> probably top 5 D in the recent times; amazing player
Dewsick -> great CTF skills even when his shape is not there; top CTF player
Fallacy -> can't remember playing him lately but some months ago he was really good
TOP O: Rain -> maybe thats just my opinion but hes a fantastic allround attacker which is very difficult to control; after serenity would be my first pick
OTHERS: Vitz -> best portuguese player for the last 5 years ?!? no words just a top notch attacker; would be my top pick in a draft
Morpheus -> best allround attacker i have played with i think; can attack and help the base with same efficiency; would be my top pick in a draft
Hatchet -> amazing; no words can describe his attacking skills in open maps like Command for example
Phear -> best u.s.a. player i already played with/against; would make any team a favourite to win the tittle
Sonic -> probably the top attacker i have been played in the pugs lately; combination of fragging with fast flag running which make him probably the attacker in best shape right now
Sauron -> same as sonic but maybe a little less in terms of skill (difficult to measure with players of this level); the times i played against him it was a nightmare to keep the base safe
Uenz -> top german since ClanBase days and a monster in open maps like Command
Monk -> one of the most difficult players to face; he can constantly pressure your D with the monstrous amount of grabs that he can make in any map
Riven -> top fragger + good fit as backup/third attacker
Loque -> top fragger + good fit as backup/third attacker
Devil Youa -> know him since ClanBase times top attacker
Critical -> probably the best attacker i have played with in my 13/14 years of UT99; for me will always be a must-pick player
Apokalips -> probably the best flag runner i have played with in my 13/14 years of UT99; for me will always be a must-pick player
Ghozt -> top player since TF clan; i really enjoy his attacking skills
Senad -> top attacker for some time already; i really enjoy his attacking skills
Sens -> probably the best UK attacker I have played against; same as hatchet and uenz a monster in Command
I will try to keep this list updated in the next days...